I'm watching the series "Star Trek: Starfleet Academy."
As a Star Trek fan, I find the series awful.
What about you? What's your opinion?

... Nothing is impossible until it is sent to a committee.

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Linux/64)
* Origin: Gods69 BBS (21:3/220)

G69,

I'm watching the series "Star Trek: Starfleet Academy."
As a Star Trek fan, I find the series awful.
What about you? What's your opinion?

Don't even get me started. Paramount just doesn't know what to do with all the money they clearly have to make a good show.

They lost me at Star Trek: Discovery. That Michael chick, like who cast her, jeez! But, it was one of the first "new" things out of Star Trek universe and I was willing to give it a try. Waste... of... time...

The best thing about that entire show was Philippa Georgiou (played by Michelle Yeoh). Then they teased us with Section 31, where she'd be the lead, and they, and instead of a TV show they made a movie, which was an absolute abomination and waste of everyone's time and her talent.

In the meantime Picard came out and they got me back to liking them, to an extent. Not 100% my kind of Picard (especially being a TNG fan), however, with some episodes directed by Jonathan Frakes, I was, for the most part, happy.

They, to an extent, hit a home run with Strange New Worlds. I really like Anson Mount playing Christopher Pike... While still a bit fantastical, it was much closer to the Star Trek I remember. Entire cast, without a fail, grew on me and I really ended up liking them all.

Now, onto your question, re: Star Fleet Academy

... Short answer: WTF!? $%^&*(*&^%$%^&*

Gene Roddenberry is spinning in his grave!

I gave it a try, two episodes, thinking maybe it'll grow on me. It really did not. They way everyone behaves, screams, plays childish games, Nahla Ake (chancellor of the academy) acting like a 5-year old, first "lounging" in captain's chair on the ship (fine, funny once), but then spinning in chair while talking serious stuff with her staff, talking to everyone while laying on her back, walking around barefoot, seriously ... Set phasers on KILL, and just shoot met now. Just DO IT!

Also, all this rivalry between cadets, sure somehow the show will make them grow to like one another and become this great, very capable team, but it lacks the CORE of what Star Trek was all about.

Humans were simply a better version of what we are in 2026 (for the most part). Not after leaving Starfleet Academy, but in general, and ESPECIALLY those joining the Starfleet Academy.

I am certain the Academy did not recruit a bunch of uneducated inbreeds into whom self-discipline, integrity, rational thought, scientific curiosity, diplomacy over violence, duty to serve, HONOR, tolerance, loyalty, respect for law, and sacrifice will somehow just be instilled... Give me a break.

Shit humans do not become great officers and leaders (at least in Star Trek). Now, in real world - that's a different story :)

Cheers,

|15C|13l|05oud|15D|13a|05ncer
|08 @ 911:1614/0 .. 21:3/226 .. 1:226/20 .. 46:1/117 .. 1337:3/224

... Read messages, not taglines

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A49 2024/05/29 (Linux/64)
* Origin: -= bbs.silfenpath.com | Columbus, Ohio (USA) =- (21:3/226)

I'm watching the series "Star Trek: Starfleet Academy."
As a Star Trek fan, I find the series awful.
What about you? What's your opinion?

As a long time fan and a long time member of STARFLEET International, I must say that I am really enjoying. And yesterdays dedication to Avery Brooks was really very good. I'm also enjoying the interplay between the Academy and the War College cadets.

-FCapt Dallas Vinson
-STARFLEET, The International Star Trek Fan Association

-Dallas Vinson, SysOp
-Legends of Yesteryear
- loy.hopto.org:2323

... What does it mean to pre-board? Do you get on before you get on?

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Windows/64)
* Origin: Error 404 BBS (21:2/105)

Don't even get me started. Paramount just doesn't know what to do with
all the money they clearly have to make a good show.

- "Discovery", don't like the Michael Burnham character/role.
- "Picard" and "Strange new Worlds", i liked to watch.

Now, onto your question, re: Star Fleet Academy
I gave it a try, two episodes, thinking maybe it'll grow on me. It
really did not. They way everyone behaves, screams, plays childish

I agree with you.It's becoming painful to watch...

... Everyone hates me because I'm paranoid.

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Linux/64)
* Origin: Gods69 BBS (21:3/220)

Re: Star Trek: Starfleet Acadeny
By: Gods69 to All on Fri Feb 06 2026 21:39:43

I'm watching the series "Star Trek: Starfleet Academy." As a Star Trek fan, I find the series awful. What about you? What's your opinion?

When it was first announced, I was really skeptical. I thought they'd treat it like some 90210 in space or something similar, however, so far, that hasen't happened and I've been quite happy with the episodes. It helps that there are some familiar faces in the mix. I am a bit disappointed that it takes place in the far futue Federation, but I can see why they did it; allowing them to explore new angles without having to try and stick to established canon.

One aspect of the show I'm not clear on is the existance of the War College. I don't believe this was mentioned in STD. I'd like some background on these folks.
--- SBBSecho 3.36-Linux
* Origin: End Of The Line BBS - endofthelinebbs.com (21:2/101)

I'm watching the series "Star Trek: Starfleet Academy."
As a Star Trek fan, I find the series awful.
What about you? What's your opinion?

I haven't seen it... yet. But I will give it a shoot and watch an episode or two. It'll probably suck. :)

Can it be crappier than ST:Discovery? Hated that show and I didn't like captain Burnham. Georgiou was ok and I also liked Saru. And wtf was the deal with the klingons? Even worse than ST:TOS-klingons.

However, I liked ST:Picard. It grew on me. And ST:Strange New Worlds was really good. It dipped a bit in season 3 but s1-2 was terrific. It had one of the best crossovers ever. And ST:Lower Decks is great too.

I miss ST:Enterprise. Such a great series.

Gruj

... They say there's always one weirdo on the bus, but I couldn't find them!

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Windows/64)
* Origin: Retro32 BBS (21:1/215)

Re: Star Trek: Starfleet Acadeny
By: Gods69 to All on Fri Feb 06 2026 09:39 pm

I'm watching the series "Star Trek: Starfleet Academy." As a Star Trek fan, I find the series awful. What about you? What's your opinion?

My wife and I are both Star Trek fans, and we just watched the first episode last night. We actually enjoyed it. Personally I'm not sure it would be my favorite series, but the episode kept our interest and seemed interesting. I enjoyed it better than Discovery's first season (I was really dubious about Discovery when it first started, due to the changed appearance of the Klingons and advanced-looking technology, etc.).

Also though, ever since Discovery jumped so far into the future and stayed there, I've been dubious about any Star Trek content being set that far in the future, as it means they now have to take the future (as well as the past) into consideration in Star Trek canon. When Discovery went into the future, I thought that perhaps at some point they'd find a way to go back to their own time (meaning the future would still be unwritten), but they didn't do that.

Nightfox
--- SBBSecho 3.34-Linux
* Origin: Digital Distortion: digdist.synchro.net (21:1/137)

Re: Re: Star Trek: Starfleet Acadeny
By: CloudDancer to Gods69 on Fri Feb 06 2026 05:52 pm

They lost me at Star Trek: Discovery. That Michael chick, like who cast her, jeez! But, it was one of the first "new" things out of Star Trek universe and I was willing to give it a try. Waste... of... time...

The best thing about that entire show was Philippa Georgiou (played by Michelle Yeoh). Then they teased us with Section 31, where she'd be the lead, and they, and instead of a TV show they made a movie, which was an absolute abomination and waste of everyone's time and her talent.

They, to an extent, hit a home run with Strange New Worlds. I really like Anson Mount playing Christopher Pike... While still a bit fantastical, it was much closer to the Star Trek I remember. Entire cast, without a fail, grew on me and I really ended up liking them all.

I do like Strange New Worlds. Still, I keep wondering why they had been doing those prequel (pre-Kirk) series for a while. Star Trek: Enterprise was interesting, but then when Discovery came out, I started wondering why they wanted to do yet another pre-Kirk series. Then Strange New Worlds, same thought, but that is a good show.

For a long time, I've thought that if they wanted to do a sort of prequel Star Trek show, it would be interesting if they made a show about the Enterprise B or Enterprise C, since we only saw each of those once in Star Trek canon. A show or a series of movies about thsoe would be interesting, I think.

Other than that, I'd like to see more Star Trek shows that are set after TNG, DS9, and Voyager. And I was dubious about anything set 800+ years in the future, as they ended up doing with Discovery, and now Starfleet Academy.

Nightfox
--- SBBSecho 3.34-Linux
* Origin: Digital Distortion: digdist.synchro.net (21:1/137)

Re: Star Trek: Starfleet Acadeny
By: Mortar M. to Gods69 on Sat Feb 07 2026 11:58 am

When it was first announced, I was really skeptical. I thought they'd treat it like some 90210 in space or something similar, however, so far, that hasen't happened and I've been quite happy with the episodes. It helps that there are some familiar faces in the mix.

My wife & I just watched the first episode of it last night, and we enjoyed it too.

I am a bit
disappointed that it takes place in the far futue Federation, but I can see why they did it; allowing them to explore new angles without having to try and stick to established canon.

I think the problem with having Star Trek series set so far into the future is that now, they have to take the future into consideration, in addition to the past, in Star Trek canon now. When making more Star Trek content, they now need to make sure they won't do anything that would break past canon as well as making sure the future makes sense.

Nightfox
--- SBBSecho 3.34-Linux
* Origin: Digital Distortion: digdist.synchro.net (21:1/137)

Re: Re: Star Trek: Starfleet Acadeny
By: Gruj to Gods69 on Sat Feb 07 2026 07:29 pm

However, I liked ST:Picard. It grew on me. And ST:Strange New Worlds was really good. It dipped a bit in season 3 but s1-2 was terrific. It had one of the best crossovers ever. And ST:Lower Decks is great too.

I think Picard season 3 was the best season of the show. And I really like Lower Decks and Strange New Worlds too. I didn't think Strange New Worlds dipped at all in season 3; I enjoy all of it, and I'm looking forward to the next seasons.

Nightfox
--- SBBSecho 3.34-Linux
* Origin: Digital Distortion: digdist.synchro.net (21:1/137)

Other than that, I'd like to see more Star Trek shows that are set after TNG, DS9, and Voyager. And I was dubious about anything set 800+ years
in the future,

I haven't seen the DS9 series yet. Is a good one ?

... This computer will self-destruct in 5 seconds.

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Linux/64)
* Origin: Gods69 BBS (21:3/220)

On 08 Feb 2026, Gods69 said the following...

I haven't seen the DS9 series yet. Is a good one ?

Back in the day I couldn't get into DS9. Just a couple of years ago someone suggested starting with season 3, which we did.

We ended up watching the series all the way through from that point. Once we got to the end we started back and went through seasons 1-2.

I still would say Season 3+ is better than 1 & 2, but after finishing the series we were invested in the characters which made it easier.


Jay

... After all is said and done, a hell of a lot more is said than done

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A49 2024/05/29 (Linux/64)
* Origin: Northern Realms (21:3/110)

Re: Re: Star Trek: Starfleet Acadeny
By: Gods69 to Nightfox on Sun Feb 08 2026 08:54 am

Other than that, I'd like to see more Star Trek shows that are set after
TNG, DS9, and Voyager. And I was dubious about anything set 800+ years
in the future,

I haven't seen the DS9 series yet. Is a good one ?

I like it, though if you're used to TOS, TNG, and Voyager, I think DS9 took a bit of time to get used to.

When DS9 first aired originally, it was a bit different from typical Star Trek in that it was set on a space station rather than a starship. I think it also had more political stuff in it than other Star Trek series. At first I didn't like it quite as much as the other Star Trek series and only watched it sporadically, but eventually I watched all of DS9, and I enjoyed it.

Nightfox
--- SBBSecho 3.34-Linux
* Origin: Digital Distortion: digdist.synchro.net (21:1/137)

I'm watching the series "Star Trek: Starfleet Academy."
As a Star Trek fan, I find the series awful.
What about you? What's your opinion?

It's shallow, inconsistent, and breaks with Star Trek canon in a hundred different ways.

My best guess is that the producer (Alex Kurtzman) is trying to appeal to a completely new audience because competing with the best of previous Star Treks is a tall order. It's a way to milk the franchise without contributing anything of merit.

---Xeno

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A49 2024/05/29 (Linux/64)
* Origin: 2o for beeRS>>20ForBeers.com:1337 (21:2/150)

It's shallow, inconsistent, and breaks with Star Trek canon in a hundred different ways.

I agree. Only the old S.T actors save the show...

... A light heart lives long. (Shakespeare)

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Linux/64)
* Origin: Gods69 BBS (21:3/220)

When DS9 first aired originally, it was a bit different from typical
Star Trek in that it was set on a space station rather than a starship.
I think it also had more political stuff in it than other Star Trek series.

So, is more like Babylon 5 series ?

... You scratch my tape, and I'll scratch yours.

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Linux/64)
* Origin: Gods69 BBS (21:3/220)

My wife & I just watched the first episode of it last night, and we enjoyed it too.

The first is not bad but the next episodes are more difficult to watch...

... Where there's a will, there's a lawyer.

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Linux/64)
* Origin: Gods69 BBS (21:3/220)

Back in the day I couldn't get into DS9. Just a couple of years ago someone suggested starting with season 3, which we did.
We ended up watching the series all the way through from that point.
Once we got to the end we started back and went through seasons 1-2.

OK. I've the season 6 somewhere in DVD... I don't know if this is best to see at this point. Maybe to see a little if i like or not.

... All programmers want arrays!

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Linux/64)
* Origin: Gods69 BBS (21:3/220)

Re: Star Trek: Starfleet Acadeny
By: Gods69 to All on Fri Feb 06 2026 09:39 pm

I'm watching the series "Star Trek: Starfleet Academy."
As a Star Trek fan, I find the series awful.
What about you? What's your opinion?

The promotional material I have seen suggests it is a romcom so I entirely skipped it.

I have heard a video of a Mr. Spock doll sitting on a chair got more audience than the first episode of the series, which I find brutal myself.


--
gopher://gopher.richardfalken.com/1/richardfalken
--- SBBSecho 3.34-Linux
* Origin: Palantir * palantirbbs.ddns.net * Pensacola, FL * (21:2/138)

Re: Re: Star Trek: Starfleet Acadeny
By: Gods69 to Nightfox on Mon Feb 09 2026 10:20 am

When DS9 first aired originally, it was a bit different from typical
Star Trek in that it was set on a space station rather than a starship. I
think it also had more political stuff in it than other Star Trek series.

So, is more like Babylon 5 series ?

I've never watched Babylon 5, so I couldn't say.

Nightfox
--- SBBSecho 3.34-Linux
* Origin: Digital Distortion: digdist.synchro.net (21:1/137)

Re: Re: Star Trek: Starfleet Acadeny
By: Gods69 to Nightfox on Mon Feb 09 2026 10:24 am

My wife & I just watched the first episode of it last night, and we
enjoyed it too.

The first is not bad but the next episodes are more difficult to watch...

We've watched a couple more episodes and are still enjoying it. What do you find difficult to watch about it?

Nightfox
--- SBBSecho 3.34-Linux
* Origin: Digital Distortion: digdist.synchro.net (21:1/137)

I'm watching the series "Star Trek: Starfleet Academy."
As a Star Trek fan, I find the series awful.
What about you? What's your opinion?

The promotional material I have seen suggests it is a romcom so I entirely skipped it.

I have read some of the early reviews that also suggested same. One
mentioned something about "horny teenagers." As I am well past that point
in my life, that made it uninteresting.


* SLMR 2.1a * PRESS To test. <click> RELEASE to detonate.
--- SBBSecho 3.28-Linux
* Origin: Capitol City Online (21:1/175)

Re: Re: Star Trek: Starfleet Acadeny
By: Nightfox to Gruj on Sat Feb 07 2026 13:19:56

I really like Lower Decks and Strange New Worlds too. I didn't think Strange New Worlds dipped at all in season 3

One thing I'll say for SNW, it pushes the story-telling envelope sometimes. Like the episode where the crew became story-book characters, or the cross-over episode with STLD. But I think they went to far with the singing episode. That's been on other shows before, most noteably on Buffy the Vampire Slayer. It worked there, given the nature of the series, but on a ST show? FAIC, no. I understand that in season four, there's going to be an episode where some of the characters are turned into puppets; again a-la BtVS. I'm very much hoping that that's wrong.
--- SBBSecho 3.36-Linux
* Origin: End Of The Line BBS - endofthelinebbs.com (21:2/101)

Re: Re: Star Trek: SNW
By: Mortar M. to Nightfox on Tue Feb 10 2026 10:45 am

One thing I'll say for SNW, it pushes the story-telling envelope sometimes. Like the episode where the crew became story-book characters, or the cross-over episode with STLD. But I think they went to far with the singing episode. That's been on other shows before, most noteably on Buffy the Vampire Slayer. It worked there, given the nature of the series, but on a ST show? FAIC, no. I understand that in season four, there's going to be an episode where some of the characters are turned into puppets; again a-la BtVS. I'm very much hoping that that's wrong.

I like the storytelling on SNW as well. And I actually enjoyed the singing episode.. I feel like it doesn't hurt to have some sillyness in Star Trek like that (and they do a lot more sillyness on Lower Decks). But I can see why people wouldn't like that episode. I think one downside, though, is that they're only doing 10 episode per season, so that episode is 10% of the whole series. When they're only making 10 episodes per season, I think they should be careful about making an episode that a lot of people might not like. Back when TV shows often had 25-26 episodes per season, that wasn't as big of an issue (though I think there were often more episodes that people didn't care for too much or were a bit boring).

Nightfox
--- SBBSecho 3.34-Linux
* Origin: Digital Distortion: digdist.synchro.net (21:1/137)

Re: Re: Star Trek: Starfleet Acadeny
By: Gods69 to Nightfox on Sun Feb 08 2026 08:54:20

I haven't seen the DS9 series yet. Is a good one ?

Watch a few eps and find out for yourself. No one can tell you what's "good", only what /they/ thought was good.
--- SBBSecho 3.36-Linux
* Origin: End Of The Line BBS - endofthelinebbs.com (21:2/101)

downside, though, is that they're only doing 10 episode per season, so that episode is 10% of the whole series. When they're only making 10 episodes per season, I think they should be careful about making an episode that a lot of people might not like. Back when TV shows often
had 25-26 episodes per season, that wasn't as big of an issue (though

Yeah, I agree 100%. I also liked the whacky episodes but they occur too often. 1 per 10 episodes is more than enough. I'm looking forward to the puppet-episode in season 4. :)

Gruj

... Don't diet, download a virus to remove the FAT.

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Windows/64)
* Origin: Retro32 BBS (21:1/215)

So, is more like Babylon 5 series ?

Yes, both take place on a space station (more or less). Both are really great series and worth a watch. DS9 is a bit slow but really picks up the pace in season 2 (or was it 3). B5 is great almost all the way, the last season (5) is not as good as the rest.

Both series are excellent and if I have to pick one I would probably choose B5... I think...

Oh, Don't forget BSG (Battlestar Galactica). What a great series it is (the new series from 2004).

What any of them instead of the Starfleet Academy.

Gruj

... Electricity is really just organized lightning.

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Windows/64)
* Origin: Retro32 BBS (21:1/215)

I'm watching the series "Star Trek: Starfleet Academy."
As a Star Trek fan, I find the series awful.
What about you? What's your opinion?

I'm 1.5 episodes in so far. One thing struck me immediately and that's the overuse of cgi. Everything feels very plastic. And some of the characters I don't really care about. More to follow.

Gruj

... There will be a rain dance Friday night, weather permitting!

--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A48 (Windows/64)
* Origin: Retro32 BBS (21:1/215)

Re: Re: Star Trek: Starfleet Acadeny
By: Gruj to Gods69 on Tue Feb 10 2026 21:16:36

B5 is great almost all the way, the last season (5) is not as good as the rest.

There's a reason for that: When JMS first created the series, he intended to have a five-season story arc. However, stuff happens and he was forced to do it in four. When he learned he could have a fifth season, he had to scramble to come up with a new arc. It wasn't bad, but it did feel a bit disjointed. It's still one of my favorite sci-fi shows.
--- SBBSecho 3.37-Linux
* Origin: End Of The Line BBS - endofthelinebbs.com (21:2/101)